Should chores earn points, an allowance or rewards?
Before you design a chart, decide what a ticked job is worth. You have four realistic options: stars or points, money, rewards bought with points, or nothing beyond thanks. None is right for every family, but each fits some ages and goals better than others. The tables below help you choose, and the last section shows how to combine two without muddling everyone.
The four options side by side
The AAP notes that tangible rewards such as allowances and stickers can be considered alongside honest praise. Its page on positive reinforcement through rewards adds detail: tokens like paper stars tend to suit early school-age children, while points and contract-style systems work better for older kids.
| Option | What the child gets | What it teaches | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stars or points | A visible tally, sometimes a sticker | Progress you can see | Losing meaning once nothing follows |
| Allowance | Money, weekly or per job | Earning, saving, choosing | Kids turning down jobs they don’t need money for |
| Rewards | Privileges or treats bought with points | Saving up for something chosen | Inflation: costs creeping lower and lower |
| Nothing extra | Thanks and a share in a working home | Chores as part of belonging | Slower start with young children |
Decision table by age
Age shapes what a reward means. A five-year-old feels a sticker right away; a twelve-year-old sees a sticker as babyish but will work steadily toward a goal three weeks out.
| Age | Strongest fit | Also works | Usually a weak fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5–6 | Stickers or stars straight after the job | Small daily rewards | Money saved for later |
| 7–9 | Stars toward a weekly reward | A small allowance | Long-term contracts |
| 10–12 | Points toward bigger goals | Allowance with a savings plan | Stickers on their own |
| 13–14 | Allowance or paid extra jobs | Points toward privileges | Charts they didn’t help design |
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s Money as You Grow guidance treats 6–12 as the age for building habits around earning, saving and shopping. If financial skills are your main reason, money starts making sense from about seven.
Decision table by goal
Ask what you most want from the system over the next six months. The answer usually points to one option.
- If you mostly want jobs done without arguments, start with stars.
- If you mostly want a child who can handle money, start with an allowance.
- If one particular job is the battle, put a reward on that job alone.
- If you want chores to feel like belonging, track them but attach nothing.
| Your main goal | Best option | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Get a new habit started fast | Stars with small, quick rewards | Immediate payoff while the habit forms |
| Teach money management | Allowance | Real choices with real money |
| Motivate one tricky job | Points toward a reward they chose | A target linked to that job |
| Build a sense of contribution | Nothing extra, plus praise | Jobs belong to being in the family |
| Pay for genuinely extra work | Money for an extras list only | Keeps everyday jobs unpaid |
| Calm sibling comparisons | Points visible per child | Effort is recorded, not argued over |
Setting up whichever you choose
The AAP’s reward guidance is practical: chart the specific behaviour with a time of day, decide the points each one earns, total them daily, keep the chart easy to see and let the child help choose rewards that matter to them. Be clear how many points a reward takes. It also advises avoiding penalties and demerits, which tend to humiliate and discourage.
Choosing “nothing extra” is a real option, not a failure. Plenty of jobs, such as clearing your own plate, can stay part of family life while a chart still tracks them, as a reminder rather than a scoreboard.
“From Monday, every job on your row earns a star. Stars add up, and on Friday you can swap them for something from the menu, which you get to help write. Stars you’ve earned are yours to keep, whatever else happens that week.”
Whatever you choose, the system is meant to fade. The AAP suggests phasing a programme out gradually once the behaviour is internalised, which often shows when a child forgets to ask for their points.
Mixing two systems without confusion
Combining options is fine if each has a separate job. One clean split: everyday jobs earn stars for rewards, and a short list of extras earns money. Children understand two rules; they get lost with five.
Everyday jobs: earn stars ⭐ 10 stars = pick Friday’s film 25 stars = stay up 30 minutes on Saturday Extra jobs (ask first): earn money 💰 Wash the car: $3 Weed the front bed: $2
sharechores handles this split in one place. Every chore carries a star value; with a paid plan you also set rewards with an emoji and a star cost, and record an allowance per star or per chore for each child. sharechores only keeps the records: you pay your child yourself. If you’re trying out the idea first, the free chart maker prints a weekly chart to tick by hand.
If money is the route you choose, settle the weekly amount before the first payday. If rewards appeal more, let your child help choose them, so the stars have something worth saving for.
Questions people ask
Is it bad to reward kids for chores?
No. The AAP treats tangible rewards like allowances and stickers as worth considering, as long as praise is honest and the system is phased out once habits stick.
Should I take points away for bad behaviour?
Avoid it. The AAP advises against penalties and demerits on reward charts because they discourage children. Handle behaviour separately and keep earned points safe.
At what age should kids start getting an allowance?
Around six or seven, when they can count and compare prices. The CFPB frames ages 6–12 as the time to build earning, saving and shopping habits.
Can I switch systems later?
Yes. Moving from stickers to points to money as children grow is normal. Announce the change at a calm moment and convert any saved stars fairly.